Homemade peanut butter cookie calories come to 95 for one 3-inch cookie (20 g) and 475 per 100 g. The number to notice is how fast that adds up: fat supplies 44% of the calories, and a few cookies from the jar can match a small meal before you register eating them.
95kcal
1 cookie · 20 g, homemade, from recipe
7%protein
1.8 gProtein
12 gCarbs
4.8 gFat
How to burn off 95 kcal
—Walking, brisk
—Jogging
—Cycling, moderate
—Swimming
Skip the math. BodyPal counts these calories from your steps and workouts automatically.
Nutrition facts
Homemade, from recipe · per 20 g
Calories
95 kcal
Protein
1.8 g
Carbohydrate
11.8 g
Fat
4.8 g
Saturated fat
0.9 g
Cholesterol
6 mg
Sodium
104 mg
Potassium
46 mg
Iron
0.4 mg
Source: USDA FoodData Central
🛡️
Verified nutrition data
Numbers on this page come from USDA FoodData Central, the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s food composition database, and from manufacturer labels where a branded product is named. Last verified September 2026. How we verify our data →
Homemade peanut butter cookie: calories, protein and sodium by serving
Percent of daily value uses the FDA reference of 2,000 kcal a day.
Serving
kcal
Protein
Carbs
Fat
Sodium
% DV kcal
1 cookie, 3 in (20 g)
95
1.8 g
11.8 g
4.8 g
104 mg
5%
Store-bought cookie (31 g)
147
2.8 g
18 g
7.4 g
144 mg
7%
1 oz portion (28 g)
133
2.5 g
16.5 g
6.7 g
145 mg
7%
100 g
475
9 g
58.9 g
23.8 g
518 mg
24%
3 × 1 cookie, 3 in (20 g)
285
5.4 g
311 mg
5 × 1 cookie, 3 in (20 g)
475
9 g
518 mg
One cookie is 95 calories, three are 285
A single 3-inch homemade cookie weighs about 20 g and carries 95 calories, 1.8 g of protein, 11.8 g of carbs and 4.8 g of fat. That is 5% of a 2000-calorie daily value. On its own, it is a modest treat.
The trouble is that peanut butter cookies rarely travel alone. Two cookies (40 g) reach 190 calories. Three (60 g) land at 285. Five cookies weigh 100 g and total 475 calories, roughly a quarter of the daily value at 24%. The jump from one to five is small on the plate and large on the log.
Size matters as much as count. A 1 oz portion (28 g) is 133 calories, so a cookie that is only slightly bigger than the 3-inch reference moves the total noticeably. If you bake your own, scooping the dough with a measured spoon keeps every cookie close to the 95-calorie mark, and weighing a finished cookie once tells you where your batch really sits.
Fat and carbs split the calories almost evenly
Per 100 g, a homemade peanut butter cookie has 58.9 g of carbs, 23.8 g of fat and 9 g of protein. In calorie terms that works out to 48% from carbs, 44% from fat and just 7% from protein. This is a sweet, rich baked good first and a peanut food a distant second.
The peanut butter does lift the protein a little compared with plain sugar cookies, but not enough to change the cookie's role. One 20 g cookie gives 1.8 g of protein, 4% of the daily value. Even three cookies supply only 5.4 g. If you want a snack that keeps you full, the protein here will not carry that job.
Saturated fat sits at 4.4 g per 100 g against a daily value of 20 g, and cholesterol at 31 mg per 100 g against 300 mg. Neither number is extreme for a homemade cookie. The fat that drives the calorie count is the bigger story than the type of fat.
Sodium is the row to watch
Peanut butter cookies are saltier than most people expect from a dessert. The recipe-based USDA row lists 518 mg of sodium per 100 g, which is 23% of the 2300 mg daily value. Salted peanut butter, baking soda and added salt in the dough all stack up.
Per cookie it looks small: 104 mg, or 5% of the daily value. Three cookies bring it to 311 mg, and five reach the full 518 mg. For comparison, the homemade chocolate chip cookie on our site has 341 mg per 100 g, so the peanut butter version runs clearly higher.
If you watch sodium, this is the easiest number to change at home. Unsalted peanut butter and a lighter hand with the salt shaker lower it without touching the calories. Potassium, at 231 mg per 100 g, is modest and does not offset much of that sodium.
Store-bought cookies are bigger, not lighter
A typical store-bought peanut butter cookie weighs 31 g and carries 147 calories, 7.4 g of fat and 144 mg of sodium. That is 7% of the daily calorie value in one cookie. The packaged version is not dramatically richer per gram; it is simply a larger cookie than the 20 g homemade reference.
The packaged row also shows numbers the recipe row does not: 8.9 g of sugars and 0.7 g of fiber per cookie. Fiber is close to zero, which is part of why one cookie does little for fullness. Brands on this page, such as Grandma's, Cougar Mountain and Wow Baking Company, vary in size, so check the label weight rather than assuming one cookie equals one serving.
A cookie fits best as a planned part of the day rather than a grazing habit. Pairing one with a glass of milk or a piece of fruit makes it feel like a snack instead of a starter for five more. BodyPal can log a cookie from a photo, which helps when a homemade batch has no label at all.
How does homemade peanut butter cookie compare?
Here is how the homemade peanut butter cookie stacks up against other snack foods, per 100 g and per usual serving.
Verdict: Per 100 g the peanut butter cookie (475) and homemade chocolate chip cookie (488) are nearly tied, so pick peanut butter for slightly more protein at 9 g versus 5.7 g, or chocolate chip for less sodium at 341 mg versus 518 mg. If you want volume for fewer calories, homemade hummus at 177 per 100 g beats both, while microwave butter popcorn at 535 per 100 g and 763 mg of sodium is the heaviest choice here.
Most popular homemade peanut butter cookie brands in the United States
Ranked by popularity in the BodyPal database
# Productkcal / 100 g
1Nature's Promise Peanut Butter Cookies2 cookies · 30 g433 kcal
How many calories are in one homemade peanut butter cookie?
A 3-inch homemade peanut butter cookie (20 g) has about 95 calories. A store-bought one (31 g) has about 147.
Are peanut butter cookies good for weight loss?
They are calorie-dense at 475 calories per 100 g, with 23.8 g of fat. One 20 g cookie adds 95 calories.
Peanut butter cookies vs chocolate chip cookies: which has fewer calories?
Homemade peanut butter cookies have 475 calories per 100 g, and homemade chocolate chip cookies have 488. The difference is small.
How much protein is in a peanut butter cookie?
One homemade cookie (20 g) has about 1.8 g of protein, 11.8 g of carbs and 4.8 g of fat. Per 100 g that is 9 g of protein.
How many calories are in three homemade peanut butter cookies?
Three 3-inch homemade peanut butter cookies (60 g) have about 285 calories, along with 5.4 g of protein and 311 mg of sodium. Two cookies come to 190 calories.
How much sodium is in a peanut butter cookie?
One 20 g homemade peanut butter cookie has 104 mg of sodium, 5% of the daily value. Per 100 g it reaches 518 mg, or 23%, which is high for a sweet.
How much fat is in a homemade peanut butter cookie?
A 3-inch homemade peanut butter cookie has 4.8 g of fat. Per 100 g that rises to 23.8 g, and fat supplies 44% of the cookie's calories.
Do store-bought peanut butter cookies have more calories than homemade?
A store-bought peanut butter cookie (31 g) has 147 calories versus 95 for a 20 g homemade one. The difference comes mostly from size, since the packaged cookie is heavier.
How many calories are in 100 g of peanut butter cookies?
100 g of homemade peanut butter cookies has 475 calories, 9 g of protein, 58.9 g of carbs and 23.8 g of fat. That is roughly five 3-inch cookies.